San Cristobal by Ashton Cigars
San Cristobal Revelation Legend (BP Toro) by Ashton Cigars

Vitola: Toro
Length: 6.2
Gauge: 52

Wrapper: Ecuadorian Sumatra
Binder: Nicaraguan
Filler: Nicaragua
Blender/Creator: Don ‘Pepin’ Garcia
Factory: My Father Cigars, Esteli, Nicaragua
Country: Nicaragua
Purchase Source:
Date Purchased: June 28, 2019
Price: $4.00
Date Smoked: December 19, 2021
Quantity: 1

San Cristobal Revelation Legend (BP Toro) by Ashton Cigars

COVID-19 Day 638
 Ecuadorian Habano Rosado, My Father, My Father No. 1, Nicaragua, No. 1, Robusto I’m anxious to get my Ecuadorian Sumatra Wrapper journey started next year in 2022, so I couldn’t resist choosing this San Cristobal Revelation Legend (BP Toro) by Ashton Cigars that I hadn’t smoked in a couple of years. I was having challenges recalling the high accolades I gave it the last few times I’ve smoked this gem. Let’s get going!

Through a very open and easy draw come familiar tobacco flavors of deep rich earthy coffee, cocoa, black pepper, and sweet cedar notes with a decent pepper spice on the retrohale… A good beginning!

Coming onto the second third, the burn performance is razor sharp… as you can kind of see to the right…

Puffing away nearing the halfway point, I realize that something is missing from this cigar… particularly the bodied tobacco flavors… they’re not as full as I had remembered or expected. I’m not saying this in a negative way, because there were several tobacco flavors that I received from this San Cristobal Revelation today, but just a side note to myself to keep my expectations in check.

I think I’ll try the Prophet (Robusto) (5.0″x54) for a change next time…
Stay Smoky
Stay Chill


Wow, a fresh start after resting this San Cristobal Revelation Legend (BP Toro) by Ashton Cigars and it’s a whole new smoking experience. This is a beautiful-looking cigar with its smooth oily wrapper enticing me all the way.

Once lit, volumes of smoke pour over me with familiar coffee tobacco flavors along with a mild retrohale that compliments the “smooth vibe” of this cigar

At the second third the retrohale ramps up with a tad more spice while some cocoa flavors are trying to come through. The draw is so seductive, I’m eager to puff on this… maybe too much. I’m diggin’ this cigar.

At the halfway point, this cigar is still pouring out a nice bit of smoke with every light puff. I think I may have read somewhere that this cigar has some Drew Estate manufacturing behind it. I’ll have to check that out.

At the last third, and the smoke production makes me happy. Plenty of smooth easy smoke to enjoy.

I think I’ll consider purchasing more of these in a smaller ring gauge next time… Stay Tuned!

Stay Smoky
Stay Chill

I’ve been looking for something new to try so I acquired a few San Cristobal Revelation cigars to also further explore some Ecuadorian Sumatra wrappers. Along with what I’ve read, this one seemed to have some promise… and I expect it will deliver… eventually

Operator Error
My hopes were high, but I think I need to condition my Revelation cigars a little more. The immediate pepper blast and dusty cocoa greeted me, but I was having challenges keeping this cigar lit.

I’ll revisit this in another month or so and see what evolves. In the meantime…

“The San Cristobal (cris-TOE-bull) Revelation is the new full-line from Ashton. Like the other San Cristobal lines, it is made by Don Pepín Garcia at My Father Cigars S.A. in Estelí, Nicaragua, with an Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper that comes from the same growers that produce VSG wrappers sitting over Nicaraguan binder and filler.” –

The Experience

Ash: Even
Draw: Tight
Smoke Output: Medium
Flavor: Cocoa
Strength: Medium
Body: Medium
Finish: Long
Value: Good
Overall Rating (1-5): 3

The Cigar

Chocolate: 3
Coffee: 2
Cream: 2
Earthy: 4
Grass/Hay: 1
Leather: 1
Pepper: 2